If history feels like a struggle in your homeschool, the problem may not be the subject—it’s the method.

When taught well, history comes alive. So how do you choose between Story of the World vs Notgrass History?

The answer depends on your child.

 

Story of the World: Engaging and Story-Driven

Story of the World presents history as a narrative, covering ancient to modern times across four volumes.

Pros:

• Highly engaging and easy to read aloud
• Brings history to life through stories
• Includes activity guides, maps, and book lists

Cons:

• Lighter on deep analysis
• May need supplementation for older students

Best for: Elementary and middle school students, or any child who needs history to feel interesting and approachable.

This curriculum works especially well for families who want open-and-go lessons with minimal prep.

Notgrass History: Deep and Structured

Notgrass History is a comprehensive, literature-rich curriculum often used from middle school through high school.

Pros:

• In-depth coverage with primary sources
• Encourages critical thinking
• Strong structure for older students

Cons:

• Heavier workload
• Less entertaining than story-based approaches
• Includes Christian worldview (optional to adapt)

Best for: Older students who are ready for deeper thinking and academic rigor.

Watch the YouTube video here.

 

Key Difference

• Story of the World: Engagement + storytelling
• Notgrass History: Depth + structure

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Story of the World if your child:

• Is disengaged or bored
• Learns best through stories
• Needs history to feel accessible

Choose Notgrass History if your child:

• Is in middle or high school
• Is ready for deeper analysis
• Needs a complete, structured program

Many homeschool families use both—starting with Story of the World in younger years, then transitioning to Notgrass for high school.

Final Thoughts

If history hasn’t been working, you’re not failing—you’re refining your approach.

The right curriculum can turn history from a chore into one of the most meaningful subjects in your homeschool.

 

story of the world vs notgrass, homeschool history curriculum comparison, best homeschool history program, notgrass history review, story of the world review, homeschool history tips