Writing is one of the subjects homeschool parents worry about most. Are we teaching enough grammar? Enough creativity? Enough structure?
When you compare Institute for Excellence in Writing (IEW) and Brave Writer, you are really comparing two different philosophies of teaching writing—not simply two different curricula.
Watch this review on YouTube. Click this link.
IEW vs Brave Writer
IEW: Structure Before Independence
Created by Andrew Pudewa, IEW takes a highly structured, step-by-step approach. Students learn specific writing techniques, study models, take notes, imitate good writing, use checklists, and gradually apply what they have learned to their own work.
Think of IEW like learning music: you learn the scales before composing your own songs.
This approach can be especially helpful for analytical learners, reluctant writers, and families who want clear expectations and measurable progress. It also develops skills such as note-taking and listening to instruction that can be valuable for future academic work.
The downside? The structure can eventually feel formulaic. In our experience, after about six months, my children began to find the predictable routine a little boring.
Brave Writer: Love Language First
Brave Writer, created by homeschool mom Julie Bogart, begins from almost the opposite direction.
Rather than emphasizing writing techniques first, Brave Writer focuses on developing a child’s love of language and confidence as a writer. Lessons may include literature discussions, poetry, copywork, dictation, journaling, freewriting, and “Poetry Tea Time.”
It can feel much less like traditional school.
Brave Writer may be a particularly good fit for creative children, avid readers, children who resist worksheets, and relaxed or Charlotte Mason-inspired homeschool families.
The tradeoff is that it requires more parental involvement. You create the atmosphere, discuss books, encourage ideas, and adapt lessons. Progress can also be harder to measure.
Which One Is Right for Your Family?
If you want explicit instruction, organization, clear progression, and academic writing skills, I’d lean toward IEW.
If you value creativity, relationships, flexibility, and a love of language, Brave Writer may be the better fit.
And remember: one child may thrive with IEW while another flourishes with Brave Writer.
Neither philosophy is universally better. The best writing curriculum is the one your children engage with and that you can actually enjoy teaching.
I’ve used IEW with my own children, and we made a lot of progress. We also experienced some of the boredom that can come with a highly structured approach.
What has worked for your family? Have you used IEW, Brave Writer, or both? Share your experience in the comments—it may help another homeschool parent make this decision!
